type in your query to search makeyougohmm
Things that ... make you go hmmtechnology music video art news reviews and muse on the web

September 10, 2007

Textamerica linkrot, going commercial only, closing accounts, redirecting links

blogs and podcasting, photoshop it, How To — by TDavid @ 8:14 am PST
New! F = please no more posts like thisD = not among your best stuffC = average postB = good post, I liked itA = great post, please create more like this (Hmm, no ratings yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

Remember the moblogging site Textamerica.com (TA)? In 2003/2004 when this blog was getting off the ground, TA was a site with some promise and hype. And then Flickr rose in prominence and pretty much killed them in the moblogging popularity space, and yet they still limp along.

Textamerica going commercial only

When I used a camera phone I sent pics to my picture blog at tdavid.textamerica.com. A Hmm search says I linked to them in 18 past posts. Those links now are all redirecting to the main textamerica.com site. Did I ever get any email from them saying they closed my account? Not that I know of, but a look at their terms of service indicates (emphasis mine):

Textamerica.com reserves the right to cancel any person’s registration and to remove any materials related to such member without notice or cause.

I hadn’t sent any pictures to them in a long time, so perhaps inactivity might have been what prompted them to axe my account? Or maybe it was posts like this one: Textamerica hardware upgrade has some members wondering: where did our pictures go?

Whatever the case, it doesn’t really matter because Textamerica is going to be for commercial account only (unless you are one of the few with a lifetime personal account):

As of November 1, 2007, Textamerica is transitioning into being a Commercial Only Service Provider and will no longer support individual users with personal account moblogs unless they hold a Lifetime Membership. All non-commercial account holders who do not hold a Lifetime Membership have until November 30, 2007 to archive and remove existing images and/or videos.

This Textamerica rise and fall for personal moblogging reminds me of why I’m reluctant to spend a significant time at third party sites. Even if the sites are mega cool (which, in retrospect, Textamerica never really was) and getting a ton of hype, I’ve seen so many Textamericas come and go that it makes it harder for me to get too involved elsewhere. This cynicism might have a lot to do with why I haven’t been an avid visitor of Flickr, Facebook, MySpace and so on. I have boarded the Second Life ship (which on some days seems like the Titanic), but that’s more because I’m fascinated in where the virtual world space is headed in the future, not only or even primarily Second Life. I’m part of a group blog at VTOReality.com that actively follows this space. So far the successes seem to be more about gaming than business, but there are some notable exceptions.

I digress. Let’s get back to linkrot like Textamerica.

How to deal with linkrot on your blog
Now that Hmm has 18 posts containing links to pages that Textamerica is redirecting to its homepage, how should I deal with these posts/links? Here’s what I am doing, but am open to additional suggestions/advice/feedback:

1. removing all hyperlinks to textamerica.com except the one in this post
2. where the post doesn’t make sense without the linked page/image, I’m adding an update text with a link to this post in brackets [like this]. These days I try to make very few posts that rely on content linked from a third party site, so even if the site goes down or changes like Textamerica has, the post will still make sense. Linkrot sucks.

I was tempted to delete some of these old posts, particularly the shorter ones with little other content, but that would be breaking my own links. How do you handle linkrot in your blog archives? Do you fix the broken links or just leave them broken? Every blog out there that links out to third party sites is subject to linkrot in varying degrees. The question is how to deal with it as your blog grows? My current strategy is when this comes up deal with it. I probably should have a more structured linkrot maintenance plan. Do you?

Update 9:47am PST: Updated all 18 archived posts with links to Textamerica and my now defunct moblog there. Along the way, I found broken links to other places in the same posts and removed those as well.

Related Posts

RSS Feed comments for this post 4 Comments »

  1. I completely share your hesitance to surrender any of my personal content to third-party sites because - no matter what promises they make to you - they’ll always be a third party. I learned my lesson when Yahoo bought GeoCities and I never looked back.

    The result has been a lot of brute-forcing on my part to integrate all manner of typically third-party services into my website. I don’t mind using sites like FaceBook or MySpace, but I don’t make a habit of committing any sort of original content to them. The only major concession I’ve made in that regard is to Flickr, because no one’s going to get to see all of those photos arranged so well otherwise.

    (Flickr would make such a killing with a branded server-app; of course, Blogger promised that for years, and I don’t know anyone who got one.)

    As for Linkrot: I have a policy of never deleting, or even substantially editing, any past blogs. It’s not only to preserve the intent of my own writing, but to try to avoid causing linkrot for others. Even when I converted from Blogger to Wordpress I left my old archives up.

    In general, if I hit potentially debilitating linkrot to some external form of my own content (or, even a *hint* of a future issue) I find a way to re-host the entirety content on my own server, as I did with prior audio and photos posted from my camera.

    When it comes to linkrot to domains that have gone poof, or blogs that have rearranged their permalink structure, I plan to start re-linking to the corresponding content on Archive.org on a rolling seven-year lag basis. I’m not sure how I plan to handle sites that *are* still up now - do I trust that if they lasted for seven years they’ll last unto eternity? On the flipside, if no suitable link replacement exists the chances are I won’t even remember what the point of the link was, and the post will just live on with its dadaist self.

    Comment by peter — September 11, 2007 @ 10:02 am PST

  2. Wow, Peter, you really have thought things through. Thank you for the in-depth, detailed feedback. I like the part about your 7-year plan. I’d be curious what the percentage of linkrot is over 7 years. I wouldn’t be surprised if it was around 90% of the links rotting which means if that is accurate there is going to be a ton of content pages on the web in 7 years with broken links. Sooner or later I also wouldn’t be surprised if the search engine algorithms figured this out and rewarded pages where links aren’t rotting.

    Comment by TDavid — September 11, 2007 @ 12:11 pm PST

  3. This entire discussion has been a major topic on the CK-homefront, as I’ve been trolling through my archives all year to point my backlinks into WordPress (plus all sorts of other fun stuff like remastering old podcast audio).

    I actually made a communications plan.

    Seven years was an arbitrary pick, since that’s how old my blog currently is and I’m just getting started on the linkrot issue. Someone like you - a much more active linker - could do an interesting study by choosing a cross-section of links of different years of age to see where the rot levels off. (Kottke would be a good test-case; if I knew how to code this stuff up automatically I’d be smelling a memetacular side-project.)

    I’ve always assumed that Google tacitly rewards sites that don’t cause rot simply because more functional links point into that site for a longer amount of time.

    Comment by peter — September 11, 2007 @ 12:46 pm PST

  4. […] from usual suspects: this week TDavid and I chatted about link rot and social networking. Kottke posted a highly addictive web-game, Bloxorz. I grew bored in 15 […]

    Pingback by Crushing Krisis » Uncluttering — September 16, 2007 @ 9:13 pm PST


TrackBack URI: http://www.makeyougohmm.com/20070910/4785/trackback/

Leave a comment


By leaving a comment you consent to the Official Hmm Comment Policy

Return Home


Copyright 2003-2008 KMR Enterprises All Rights Reserved