Comprehensive IE7 beta 2 review [12 screenshots] |
Microsoft keeps tinkering around with Internet Explorer 7 readying it for an official release later this year or first part of next with the consumer version of Vista. You can take IE7 Beta 2 for a test drive, their third official beta iteration (despite being called beta 2) on a non-production system. The official IE7 blog announced the launch last night:
We believe that IE7 - even at this beta stage - is a significant improvement and we want as many people as possible to try it and use it. IE7 is feature complete and has been through significant compatibility and reliability testing. People (especially technology enthusiasts) will have a good experience with it.
In February we stepped the last IE7 beta version through the paces complete with instructions for how to uninstall. That post will be used as a reference for seeing how Microsoft has done with nearly 90 more days of time to work through the feedback. Let’s get it on:
After downloading and doubleclicking the IE7BETA2-WindowsXP-x86-enu.exe you’ll see the somewhat ominous warning to backup your files and close all other running programs:

This screen is different only in the word “preview” no longer being present. Then it’s onto validating your copy of Windows before you can proceed.

After successful validation there is an option default checked to install the malicious software removal tool. I left it checked and continued.

Now comes the time where the perspiration begins and you hope that Microsoft has done its homework and your system will reboot successfully. But you are using a non-production system, right? You backed up your files, right? If so, then proceed. If not, then proceed at your own risk.

After rebooting, programs I normally use with Firefox we’re launched which include ScreenGrab Pro and Photoshop.

The opening screen — the familiar runonce2 file — gives you a chance to configure the following (pictured above):
- Turn on automatic phishing (default OFF). I checked the box. As indicated by the warning, some sites will be sent to Microsoft for the use of this function. There is a link to an IE privacy statement.
- Help customize webpages to your current location. The radio button for “Use the current settings: English” was selected. No change.
- Join the customer experience improvement program (default: NOT checked). I left it this way. Microsoft can get my feedback from this blog in their RSS aggregator.
After making the changes above I clicked “Save your settings” and was taken to the Internet Explorer 7: Tour of New Features. Clicking on the yellow white arrow to start the tour opens up the following popup window:

Nice to see the first thing the new IE is promoting is the streamlined toolbar and interface that gives more browser window room: “say goodbye to bulky toolbars.” This is one of Opera’s strengths that the toolbar tries not to get in the way.
Going through the other tour pages, we learn that there is an “optimized design” which includes tigher menus and more focus on using up less, not more room. This will be a hit with users. Very few want to give up extra browsing space for crap they can’t configure.
The tabbed browsing is spotlighted next. Whereas the last version it seemed a bit clunky, this version is more solid.
The search bar has MSN as the default, but by clicking the dropdown menu you can be taken to a page to quickly and easily add Google and other search engines as options. Thanks Microsoft for making this convenient. I found this so friendly that there was hesitation in making Google the default. See what being good to users does for you?
If you want to add your own site search engine IE7 uses the OpenSearch format, which is handy, because we already have a search for that.
How to Add MakeYouGoHmm search to IE7
When OpenSearch was launched a little over a year ago, we jumped on adding an OpenSearch option for Hmm so the entire archives could be searched conveniently.
Unfortunately when I checked the OpenSearch Description File isn’t compatible with IE7, so I visited the A9 OpenSearch Description specs and downloaded a new example and tweaked our existing MakeYouGoHmm OpenSearch XML file. Basic changes made were the URL format and the OpenSearch description which had changed from version 1.0 to version 1.1. Result: You can now add MakeYouGoHmm to IE7 by clicking the link below.
Click here to add Hmm search inside Internet Explorer 7

Now when you do a test search for “opensearch” under MakeYouGoHmm you’ll see results from this blog that look like this inside IE7:

Even though the OpenSearch format hasn’t really caught on, I still think it’s a good idea. Opensearch allows sharing search results across a common format which MakeYouGoHmm fully supports. If you do a search here on the site or in your browser, you still have to come to this site to get the full page content which I see as a win-win for the publisher and the subscriber.
RSS integration
Internet Explorer 7 comes with a built-in RSS reader that takes a similar path as Safari, unfortunately there is no slider like Safari where you can view headlines only.

RSS reader integration in the tour is promoted as: “Don’t waste time checking many different sites and blogs for updates.” Just visit sites and if they have RSS autodiscovery the feed icon will illuminate orange as shown below (left and circled in red) vs. a site that doesn’t have a feed (right):


In the case of Hmm, we offer both Atom or RSS 2.0 feeds, so a dropdown allows readers to choose, which I realize might be confusing to some readers. Perhaps I should do some research about only giving them one or the other instead of making readers choose.
Subscribed to Hmm to test the RSS reading experience inside the browser:

On the right side a non-scrolling menu allows various sort options: by date (ascending or descending order), title, author or category. Pretty basic stuff and definitely not likely to replace my current workflow using Reblog. Maybe it will have some more features and be something more interactive and involved by the time the final IE version emerges.
IE7 extras
Microsoft offers a handy IE7 checklist for consumers, developers and IT professionals.
They also are offering FREE phone support. Are you freaking kidding me? Phone support for a beta product from Microsoft? Yes, they are. This comes from the same folks that are willing to charge $200+ to troubleshoot Outlook after you have already paid $500 for Office Professional. I didn’t call the number 1-866-876-4926, but it’s a curious move considering their history with support being an extra get into our back pocket move. Progressive thinking on their part or desperation, readers can decide. Thank you Firefox for pushing Microsoft.
Other reviews/opinions on IE 7 Beta 2
Lots of others have been peeking under the IE7 hood since last night and now that I’ve written our review I’m starting to venture out and check out what others are saying. I’ll update this section with more interesting comments as I come across them, but I wanted to publish this before too much more time went by.
Loren links up a list of IE7 addons
Jeremiah Owyang conducts a podcast interview with the IE team.
Nathan points some important details like: “Do not reinstall Windows after installing IE7. Instead, uninstall IE7, then reinstall Windows, then reinstall IE7.”
Tom Raftery points out the clever timing of a recent PC Mag column by John Dvorak that suggests Microsoft should abandon IE altogether and fix the OS security issues
Final thoughts
As I looked through this release I couldn’t help thinking that Microsoft really screwed up by saying they weren’t going to update IE until Vista came out. Yes, they backpeddled but this gaffe could turn out to be their browser’s undoing. It gave a percentage of people the reason to look elsewhere.
Being able to be the default when you boot up the OS is significant, but by the time IE7 finally comes out officially too many of their customers might already have defected. There are a lot of M$ customers who won’t install beta software and some who are freaked out about installing first release software from Microsoft. Many already have defected. A place for them to push into and be the only game in town, no pun intended, could be providing an Intenet Explorer for Xbox Live. I keep thinking as I’m playing, boy I wish I could check ___ on the web while in there … will we see this in the next year?
The Xbox Live Marketplace could be the holy grail for Microsoft on a number of fronts which I’ll expand on in a separate post, but this is an area where they have huge potential. As for the browser wars? IE7 isn’t going away, which is a good thing. This release cements their place at the very least as being serious.
Related Posts- A9 OpenSearch
- XP Service Pack 2 includes IE popup blocking by default
- Internet Explorer 7 a (beta) reality this summer
- Here we blow again: the embarassing IE7 launch
- IE7 makes it easier to add custom site search
- Microsoft Watch bets on Internet Explorer upgrade before Longhorn




It doesn’t seem like IE7 offers anything you can’t get in Firefox or Opera. Seems like they’re playing catch-up and damage control — and that’s all.
Comment by Sterling Camden — April 25, 2006 @ 4:57 pm PST
[…] Comprehensive IE7 beta 2 Review from Make you go Hmmmm […]
Pingback by Internet Explorer 7 for Download » Tips and Tricks to help you Master Your Computer — April 25, 2006 @ 5:01 pm PST
I take it you aren’t using your Xbox as a Media Center Extender, since there is an option to run a web browser in Media Center that I’m told works pretty well on Xbox.
Comment by Nathan Weinberg — April 25, 2006 @ 5:23 pm PST
Nope Nathan, don’t have Media Center. Had MCE 2005 when it first came out and then took it back after a week. I wasn’t aware there was a way to get a browser inside Xbox Live though, I’ll have to do some checking on that one. Please anybody in the know, feel free to leave me the necessary linkage/info.
Comment by TDavid — April 25, 2006 @ 6:34 pm PST
Aha, the MCE extender browser must be what you are talkinga bout, Nathan yes/now? http://www.anpark.com/software.aspx
This thing seems to be a crippled option. I was talking about a full fledged browser in my commentary above. If one of those exists, anybody, please let me know.
Comment by TDavid — April 25, 2006 @ 6:42 pm PST
New IE7 beta2 (and live mustachioed plumber)
Need a break? Turn to IT Blogwatch, in which the latest IE7 Beta debuts in open beta. Not to mention a live performance from one of the Super Mario Brothers…
Trackback by Computerworld Blogs — April 26, 2006 @ 8:05 am PST
What If…..IE Never Happened?
With the launch of the IE7 beta, there has been some fascinating discussion about Microsoft’s track record in the Web browser market. John Dvorak, who’s no stranger to controversial, against-the-grain ideas, describes IE as “The Greatest Microsoft B…
Trackback by Mark Evans — April 26, 2006 @ 11:32 am PST
I’ve loaded IE7 Beta 2 and got to the screen that asks if I want to turn on the automatic phishing detector and what sort of language I want to use. I make the selections and then it asks me to save my settings, I duly click on the box and then another screen pops up saying that there is an error applying settings. After several tries with this I have cleared off the first download of IE7 Beta 2 in the “Add/Remove Programs” section of My Computer and downloaded again. The same thing has happened. I’ve tried swear words and then rearranging the swear words but every time I open IE7 I still get that page to fill in before I can proceed. I am able to browse but the phishing and language will be as the default settings, neither of which I want. My version of Windows has been accepted as genuine and Microsoft say, effectively, this is a Beta release, hard luck. Any ideas?
Alan
Comment by Alan Etherington — May 10, 2006 @ 6:08 am PST
Alan, I have been working on the same problem for a couple of days and finally got it resolved. I am by no means a computer whiz, just learning as I go and a lot of Google searching. What I did was I backed up my address book and mail messages in Outlook and my Favorites in Explorer. I then went to my Programs folder and opened the Internet Explorer folder. I then deleted the Explorer application (the one with the E with a ring around it) and that only. When I closed everything out and clicked on my Explorer quick launch it took me to my previous homepage that I was using on IE6. So I closed it and went to the IE7 installation that I had saved on my computer and started it, and it let me install it again and it installed it right this time. It let me get past the settings page and took me to the tour, and then I went to the Add/Remove Programs with the show updates box checked and Internet Explorer 7 showed up.
I read your post while looking for answers and you were having the exact problem I was so I wanted to pass along what worked for me. I hope it works for you too.
Comment by Kristi — May 11, 2006 @ 10:49 pm PST
Thank you for sharing your findings, Kristi
Comment by TDavid — May 11, 2006 @ 10:50 pm PST
I was having a similar problem with the “RunOnce” page in IE7 Beta displaying every time I opened the browser, but I found another (easier solution). I’m not sure if it was for the same reason, but for anyone else who might be having the issue (note that, for me, the installation, aside from giving me the “unable to apply settings” error, went smoothly, and I could see the installation in the “Add/Remove Programs” Applet):
1) Close all but one open IE window. (if you don’t, you will be prompted to do so).
2) Open the Options Dialog. (Tools->Options)
3) In the “Advanced” tab, click the “Reset Internet Explorer Settings” button.
4) At this point, IE will prompt you to make sure that you want to reset to the factory default settings. Note that this operation does NOT affect your favorites and connection settings. Click “Reset”.
5) IE will then clear your cookies, all temporary files, disable any browser add-ons (you can re-enable later if you choose) and resets the browser settings. Restart the IE7.
This fixed my error with the IE7 RunOnce (”Startup”) screen appearing every time I started the browser. I hope that other users find this helpful.
Comment by jfc — May 20, 2006 @ 6:41 am PST
Thanks for the advice, Kristi’s process seemed to be beyond me so I’ve waited patiently for my son to visit and assist me through it but he hasn’t been for the past few days. Anyway jfc’s suggestions seemed to be more simple and thus more to my ability and I’ve followed it through and it has functioned, well, I’ve been able to set up the phishing filter and language (UK English) and then able to go through the Tour and back to the Home Page so I’m sure we’ve got the problem solved. Thank you both very much for your kind attention to my problem. Alan
Comment by Alan Etherington — May 20, 2006 @ 8:26 am PST
Further to my last message, I have found that since IE7 was installed successfully I have suffered slower and slower activity generally on my computer with several crashes which is unusual for this machine, I was also unable to have Google as my preferred browser, each time I came back to IE7 I had the Microsoft page to eliminate and find Google, say that I wanted it as my preferred search engine and then all went as usual until the next time I opened IE7 when it would all start again. Whilst this was going on I found that the thing would hang and I’d not even be able to Ctrl/Alt/Del and so the only thing was to use the restart button. Not satisfactory. The standard fault checking system ran and the problem was sent on to Microsoft each time for them to analyse. I have, however, solved the problem by going back to the April 30 Restore Point and dear old IE6. The system has speeded up remarkably and I’ve had no crashes for over 24 hours now.
What I’m suggesting to any readers is “BEWARE OF IE7 Beta”. It may be in all our interests to await the release of the full IE7 if and when it becomes available.
Comment by Alan Etherington — May 26, 2006 @ 5:44 am PST
Hey Alan why don’t you do yourself a real favor and use firefox. JFC you rock I was having the same problem and your advice worked perfectly.
Comment by Dan — June 2, 2006 @ 11:57 am PST