type in your query to search makeyougohmm
Things that ... make you go hmmtechnology music video art news reviews and muse on the web

September 11, 2004

Review: Scorpions - Unbreakable is … well, breakable

music — by TDavid @ 5:36 am PST

I’m not one that believes album cover art and packaging tells anything significant about the actual musical content of the album, but I may have been wrong in this line of thinking when it comes to listening to the Scorpions new album, Unbreakable. When Iron Maiden released their new album, Dance of Death there was controversy aplenty because the album art wasn’t up to their normal quality standard, but when the album came out it was really your typical — or better than typical — Maiden album.

The Scorpions have had their share of interesting album covers ranging from Blackout’s familiar fork-eyed man busting his head through glass to the gum on a woman’s breast in Lovedrive. and all sorts of variations containing torture or sexual themes.

Some notable Scorpions album cover art through the years:

Click here to buy Scorpions - Acoustica (2001) from Amazon
A cheap Blackout knockoff with a bunch of their songs unplugged, circa 2001. According to various reviewers, this one is so bad it’s never been released in the US.

Click here to buy from Amazon Scorpions - Pure Instinct (1996)
1996. Are those nude people inside the cage with the albums? Sort of reminds of Inside the Electric Circus from W.A.S.P but with more intensity and nudity .. at least from the paint brush, if not the music.

Click here to buy Scorpions - World Wide Live from Amazon
1985 - the Scorpions best live album to date

Click here to buy Scorpions - Love At First Sting (1984) from Amazon
1984 - was there a fascination with sex and sexuality on Scorpions album covers?

Click here to buy from Amazon Scorpions Blackout 1982
1982 - the best commercial album the Scorpions ever recorded and their best cover art (nearly 20 years later to be ripped off by their own Acoustica).

Click here to buy Scorpions - Animal Magnetism (1980) from Amazon
1980 - hmm, wonder what this lady is thinking about?

Click here to buy Scorpions - Lovedrive (1979) from Amazon
1979 - one of the oddest Scorpions album covers to go along with a great album (contains “Lovedrive” and “Holiday”) to finish the 70’s and show that the Scorps would have serious commercial potential in the year’s to come. This bubblegum cover was banned and might find it harder to buy the album with the original cover shown here. If you don’t care about the cover and just want the music then Amazon has the music with the scoprion and black background as a cover.

So what did the Scorpions do for Unbreakable’s album art? They ripped a page out of the AC DC Back in Black camp with an uninspired, silver package with an embossed scorpion.

Click here to buy Scorpions - Unbreakable from Amazon
2004. One of the weakest, stinger-less album covers they’ve ever done. Not even worth blowing it up full size.

Yeah, that’s it. But here’s the real question, what exactly does this say about the music inside the unceremonial packaging?

1. “New Generation” - 4/5 - a hard, punchy scorps rocker with a slightly mellow chorus. A young chorus/choir (Jody’s Kid Choir) is employed towards the end with some impact. Normally i’m not a big fan of putting kids singing but it sort of works here.

2. “Love ‘em or leave ‘em” - 4/5 - strong, catchy chorus with strong fretwork support.

3. “Deep and dark” - 3.5 / 5 - some effective Klaus wails.

4. “Borderline” - 2 / 5 - punchy guitar riff, but vocals and chorus seem cliched. Scorpions worst enemy as far as originality is themselves; songs like this personify 2004 Scorpions.

5. “Blood Too Hot” - 2 / 5 - faster riff and backbeat, but where is the blazing solo? Solo is weak and uninspired. What’s up with the lyrics in this song? “To join the family of spiders” … is this a football game and it’s a cheer on the team song, or what?

6. “Maybe I Maybe You” - 0 / 5 - totally forgetable piano, keyboard and Klaus vocal mellow song. Odd considering the scorps are known for some great mellow rock songs like “Still Lovin’ You” that they would have an awful song like this, though their last album was an unplugged collection of songs and it is only available as an import. Reviews I’ve read have not been favorable.

7. “Someday is Now” - 3 / 5 - thundering bass line with good chorus. The music suggests a flashy solo and when one comes it is competent but too short.

8. “My City My Town” - 2 / 5 - a me too song with nothing that really stands out except the music stopping briefly and then a familiar drum fill that is used in other songs on the album. Guitar solo sounds like something off a Foreigner album.

9. “Through My Eyes” - 4.5 / 5 - best song on the CD. It has a mellow feel with hard rock chorus. This is one to crank up. It sort of reminds me of mixing Lady Starlight with The Zoo. Again the solo is just too short though. Some great Klaus screams: Through my eyyyyyees! A unique and clever song ending with an audio slowdown..

10. “Can You Feel It” - 3 / 5 - nothing sticks out here except the effects pedal for the guitar solo. Not a bad song, it is just an average Scorpions song.

11. “This Time” - 1 / 5 - this song is typical B-side rock album filler. Move along.

12. “She Said” - 4 / 5 - This is the other ballad and is better than Maybe I Maybe You but it isn’t as good as too many other scorps ballads. It sounds like something Bon Jovi wrote. The best part is the melancholy last 30 seconds: No,no,no,no,no don’t walk awayyyyyyyy.

13. “Remember The Good Times” - 3/5 - Listed as a retro garage mix, but not explained anywhere where the original mix is sort of closes the album on a confused note. The song itself has a tinty sound and it is obvious mixed from the rest.I really want to like this CD but it pales in comparison of what made the Scorps popular through the late 70s and 80s. In the video segment it says they are trying to go back to the roots but the album cover art isn’t even paying homage to those roots.

Average score = 2.76 rounded up to 3 stars. In grade terms a mere C+.

Just an average and ironically breakable effort form a band that is capable of so much more. With the recent Florida hurricane (and perhaps in poor taste), a local news station was playing the Scorpions “Rock You Like A Hurricane” which reminds folks of 80’s Scorpions arena style rock and roll. It’s too bad because some of the riffs on Unbreakable are really catchy, the guitar sounds are punchy and well produced, but the botched ballad, some weak lyrics and the overall musical de je vus just add up to exactly what is displayed on the cover art: a lack of originality.

There are a few goodies/extras on the CD for those who go that far like a video with some commentary about how they wanted to go back to their roots and how this is the best album they’ve done in “five years” but considering their last release, Acoustica, was an import-only of prior unplugged-type songs and before that they knocked off Metallica with the whole let’s get a well known symphony and record some of our popular songs with a full orchestra backing. Something just isn’t right about listening to some tuba player spazzing over the great lick he just played on “Bad Boys Running Wild.”

Unbreakable isn’t bad, but not all that good either. Maybe it’s time for the Scorpions to pull their tail in and admit that the stinger isn’t what it used to be. Average score = 2.76 rounded up to 3 stars. Grade: C+

Did this post make you go hmm?

F = please no more posts like thisD = not among your best stuffC = average postB = good post, I liked itA = great post, please create more like this (Hmm, no ratings yet)

Loading ... Loading ...

Maybe Related Posts (plugin generated)

RSS Feed comments for this post 2 Comments »

  1. i think this is the best album they have put in in like 5 years, which isnt saying much
    although there were several catchy songs on the album, i the lyrics are just terrible, for example in the song deep and dark. what the hell does that mean,
    i mean cmon i could of come up with this verse
    down, i am down
    on the ground
    sad and tired
    im down
    its over now
    yes im down
    should i like it
    what the hell why would he like it
    new generation is one of the better tracks on the cd one of the only decently written tracks
    the only other song i like is through my eyes, nicely written catchy chorus and makes me wanna listen to it more than once
    all i can really say about this album is that after 30 years , its cool that their spirit to rock hasnt faded but i agree they are definily not what they used to be

    Comment by curtis — January 17, 2005 @ 6:44 pm PST

  2. [curtis :1] Fuck you man!! 0/5 for maybe I maybe you. That’s a wonderfull ballad. If I saw you on the street I would probably kill you.

    Comment by Stefan — February 2, 2005 @ 11:12 am PST


TrackBack URI: http://www.makeyougohmm.com/20040911/1008/trackback/

Leave a comment


By leaving a comment you consent to the Official Hmm Comment Policy

Return Home

Copyright 2003-2008 KMR Enterprises All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy